...

Can They Take Money From Your Salary or Bank Account?

garnishee order south africa

When someone owes you money and refuses to pay, it can be incredibly frustrating. You have provided the service, delivered the goods or won your court case, but the money still hasn’t arrived.

Fortunately, South African law provides ways of recovering money by attaching funds or earnings that are owed to the person who owes you.

You may have heard people refer to this as a “garnishee order”. Although that term is still widely used, it is not the correct name for every type of attachment. South African law makes a distinction between attaching money owed by a third party, deducting money from someone’s salary and enforcing unpaid maintenance.

Understanding the difference is important because each process has its own rules.

The Three Ways Money Can Be Attached

Let’s look at the three main types of attachment orders and how they work.

  1. A Garnishee Order: Attaching Money Owed to Someone

A garnishee order is used when another person or organisation owes money to someone who has a court judgment against them.

For example, imagine a person owes you money following a court judgment. That person has money in a bank account, or a tenant owes them rental payments.

Instead of waiting for the debtor to pay you, you can apply to court to have the money owed to them attached and paid towards the outstanding judgment debt.

A bank account is a common example. Money held in a bank account represents an amount the bank owes its customer. A court can therefore order the attachment of that debt, subject to the legal requirements.

The same principle can apply to rental income or other money owed to the debtor by a third party.

Section 72 of the Magistrates’ Courts Act 32 of 1944 deals with this type of attachment. It allows a court to attach money that is already owed to the judgment debtor or that will become payable in future.

  1. An Emoluments Attachment Order (EAO): Deducting Money from a Salary

An Emoluments Attachment Order, commonly called an EAO, allows money to be deducted directly from someone’s salary or wages to repay a judgment debt.

The order is directed at the person’s employer, who must deduct the specified instalments from the employee’s earnings and pay them to the judgment creditor or their attorney.

For example, if someone owes money under a court judgment and cannot settle the debt in one payment, an EAO may allow the debt to be repaid through regular salary deductions.

However, an employer cannot simply start deducting money because a creditor has requested it. The requirements of section 65J of the Magistrates’ Courts Act must be followed, including court authorisation and the applicable notice and objection procedures.

  1. Maintenance

Maintenance enforcement works differently because it is governed by the Maintenance Act 99 of 1998.

If someone fails to pay maintenance as ordered by a court, the person entitled to receive the maintenance can approach the Maintenance Court for assistance.

Where a maintenance order remains unpaid for 10 days after the relevant payment becomes due, the person entitled to maintenance may apply to the court for enforcement.

Depending on the circumstances, the court can order:

  • Money to be deducted directly from the maintenance defaulter’s salary or wages.
  • Money owed to the defaulter by another person to be attached.
  • A warrant of execution against the defaulter’s property.

For example, if a parent repeatedly fails to pay court-ordered child maintenance, the Maintenance Court can order their employer to deduct the outstanding amount from their earnings.

Importantly, you do not have to employ a private attorney to approach the Maintenance Court. The maintenance office at your local Magistrates’ Court can assist you with the process and the necessary paperwork.

The Maintenance Act also covers maintenance obligations involving other persons, including spouses, where a legal duty to provide maintenance exists.

How Does the Attachment Process Work?

For ordinary civil debts, an attachment order generally follows a court judgment confirming that the money is owed.

Once judgment has been granted, the creditor can take further legal steps to recover the outstanding amount.

Applying for a Garnishee Order

Under section 72 of the Magistrates’ Courts Act, a judgment creditor may apply to court for a garnishee order. This application can be made ex parte, which means the application is brought without first notifying the judgment debtor.

The law allows this procedure because the court is being asked to attach money owed to the debtor by someone else. Giving advance notice in every case could allow the money to be moved or paid before the attachment takes effect.

The court must still be satisfied that the legal requirements have been met before granting the order.

The third party who owes the money, known as the garnishee, must also have the necessary connection with the court district. Under section 72, that person must reside, carry on business or be employed within the district.

The section also excludes debts owed by the State.

Applying for an Emoluments Attachment Order

An EAO follows a different procedure under section 65J of the Magistrates’ Courts Act.

A court must authorise the order after considering whether it is just and equitable and whether the proposed deduction is appropriate.

Once the court has authorised it, the creditor or their attorney must serve the prescribed notice on the judgment debtor and their employer. The notice must explain the outstanding amount and give them an opportunity to oppose the proposed order within 10 days after receiving it.

If the debtor or employer objects, the matter may have to be referred back to court for consideration.

The EAO must then be properly prepared, issued and served on the employer by the sheriff.

The court district is generally determined by where the judgment debtor resides, carries on business or is employed.

Once the order has been properly issued and served, the employer is legally required to make the deductions specified in the order.

What Protection Does the Law Give Someone Facing an Attachment Order?

Having money attached or deductions taken directly from your salary can put considerable pressure on your household finances.

South African law recognises that creditors are entitled to recover legitimate debts, but it also provides protection for people who would otherwise be left without enough money to support themselves and their dependants.

There are two particularly important protections.

The 25% Limit on Ordinary Salary Attachments

Section 65J(1A) of the Magistrates’ Courts Act places a limit on ordinary Emoluments Attachment Orders.

The total instalments payable under one or more EAOs may not exceed 25% of the judgment debtor’s basic salary.

For this purpose, basic salary is calculated by dividing the employee’s annual gross salary by 12. Additional remuneration for overtime and other allowances is excluded.

This means that having several creditors does not allow them to keep adding salary deductions beyond the statutory 25% limit.

It is important to understand that this restriction applies to ordinary EAOs under the Magistrates’ Courts Act. It is not a universal limit on every type of salary deduction.

Maintenance Orders Are Treated Separately

Maintenance attachment orders are governed by the Maintenance Act, not the ordinary EAO provisions of section 65J.

The 25% restriction therefore does not automatically apply to maintenance deductions made under section 28 of the Maintenance Act.

The Maintenance Court determines the amount required to enforce the maintenance obligation, taking the relevant circumstances into account.

Maintenance payments are also given priority over ordinary court-ordered deductions from an employee’s earnings under the specific provisions of the Maintenance Act.

What If the Attachment Leaves You Unable to Make Ends Meet?

You are not expected to remain silent if an attachment order leaves you without enough money to support yourself or your dependants.

Under section 72(2) of the Magistrates’ Courts Act, a garnishee order can be set aside or amended if the court is satisfied that the debtor will not have sufficient means left for their own maintenance and that of their dependants.

Section 65J also provides procedures for challenging, amending or rescinding an EAO where the deductions are excessive, the amounts claimed are incorrect, or the debtor’s remaining income is insufficient.

The court can consider the financial circumstances and may reduce the deductions, amend the order or set it aside where the legal requirements are met.

Maintenance attachment orders can also be challenged, amended or rescinded by the Maintenance Court on good cause shown.

The Takeaway

Attachment orders are an important part of South Africa’s debt recovery system. They allow creditors to recover money through a third party, an employer or the maintenance enforcement process rather than relying entirely on the debtor to make payment voluntarily.

However, the type of order matters. A garnishee order, an Emoluments Attachment Order and a maintenance attachment order are not interchangeable, and each has its own legal requirements.

Just as creditors have the right to pursue money legally owed to them, debtors have the right to fair procedures and protection against unlawful or excessive deductions.

Knowing how these orders work can help you understand your rights, whether you are trying to recover money or facing an attachment against your own income.

Need help navigating an attachment order? Whether you are challenging an unfair deduction or applying to court to recover money owed to you, contact us for expert legal guidance.

 

Leave a Reply

Seraphinite AcceleratorOptimized by Seraphinite Accelerator
Turns on site high speed to be attractive for people and search engines.